Divorce and social media

beware what you share

In an urgent application before him the Honourable Justice Chetty had to consider whether he should confirm an interim interdict ordering respondent to remove defamatory statements about applicant on her Facebook page and restraining the respondent from posting further statements in this regard. [1]

The parties were not married to each other but were the biological parents of a minor child.

Applicant regarded the postings on Respondent as defamatory and demanded that she remove it from her Facebook wall.  The posting resulted in an active debate taking place between respondent and her friends and related to an incident relating to the applicant’s care or neglect of his minor daughter.

Respondent contended that she removed the posting and that she did not consider the content thereof as defamatory.  Applicant on the other hand contended that he had a prima facie right to approach the court to ensure that his reputation was not further harmed as he considered the postings to be harmful to him as a father, but also that it could have a detrimental impact on his business reputation and character.  An interim interdict was granted.

In considering whether to grant a final interdict the court referred to a passage from H v W where it was found that it is not good enough to as a defence against defamation that the published words may be true, it must also be to the public benefit or in the public interest that they be published. ‘The courts do not pander to prurience.’ [2]

Final relief was granted in so far as the court ordered the respondent to remove the posting on her Facebook wall.

Even though you feel that your partner has wronged you it is wise to refrain from venting your frustrations on social media or any other public platform pending the finalisation of your divorce action or even subsequent to the finalisation thereof (even if your spouse cannot see your posts).  This behaviour may have an impact on your suitability to claim primary care of minor children and might be considered as alienating the minor children from your spouse.  Your spouse’s attorney might use this against you in the divorce proceedings.

[1] M v B (10175/2013) [2014] ZAKZPHC 49; 2015 (1) SA 270 (KZP) (10 September 2014)

[2] H v W [2013] 2 ALL SA 218 (GSJ)

Prescription

PRESCRIPTION

KnowLaw650

What is prescription?

  1. Prescription is when a debt (for example: an obligation to pay an amount of money) is extinguished after a certain period of time.
  2. The Prescription Act says that contractual and delictual debts extinguish after three years from the date when it became payable (due).
  3. Prescription periods may, in certain circumstances, be delayed or interrupted.

 

What are the consequences of a debt that has prescribed?

  • A person who is indebted (“debtor”) to another person (“creditor”) will not be liable to pay such debt after a certain period of time has passed.
  • This means that the creditor may not institute legal action against the debtor for such a debt. If legal action has been instituted and a special plea of prescription has been raised, the creditor will not be successful with a claim.

 

Why do I need to be aware of prescription?

 

  • South African courts do not take note of prescription out of its own accord.

 

  • Therefore the duty falls on you and/or your attorneys of record to file a special plea of prescription.

 

  • If a summons has been served on a debtor, one must always take note of when (date and year) the amount/debt was due and proceed to make the necessary calculations.

 

When does prescription commence?

  • As soon as the debt is due. A debt is due once the creditor can identify the debtor and the facts from which the debt arose.
  • A debt, which does not arise from contract, shall not be deemed to be due, until the creditor has knowledge of the identity of the debtor and of the facts from which the debt arises (example: delictual damages to a creditor).

 

When will the prescription period be delayed?

A prescription period is delayed if one of the following restrictions apply:

  • creditor is a minor, insane, or under curatorship;
  • debtor is outside South Africa;
  • creditor and the debtor are married to each other;
  • creditor and the debtor are partners and the debt arose from a partnership agreement;
  • debtor is a member of the creditor, being a governing body an organisation or business;
  • debt is the object of a dispute in an arbitration; or
  • executor of a deceased estate has not yet been appointed.

 

When will a prescription period be interrupted?

The running of prescription is interrupted by:

  • an acknowledgment of debt by a debtor, for example, if a debtor pays part of his/her debt to the creditor before prescription;

or

  • a summons served by the creditor on the debtor in order to claim payment of the debt due.
Prescription period before debt / claim is extinguished

Description of Claim / Debt

30 Years Any debt secured by a mortgage bond.

Debt in respect of a judgment delivered by a court.

6 years Debt relating to a bill of exchange, a negotiable instrument (for example, a cheque or promissory note) or a notarial contract.
3 years Debt arising from delict or contract, or any other liability.
30 years A person shall become the owner of a thing, such as piece of land, after possession for an uninterrupted period of 30 years.

 

Contempt of Court

a7dbbfdc-court

 

You have a divorce order directing your ex-husband to transfer certain shares which he holds in a private company, within a certain time from date of the order, into your name. He fails to do so. What are your rights?

A warrant of execution is not the appropriate remedy because there is no monetary amount specified in respect of the shares.

The only remedy remaining is a contempt of court application.

In order to succeed in civil contempt proceedings an Applicant has to prove the terms of the order, knowledge of these terms by the Respondent, and a failure by the Respondent to comply with the terms of the order. Upon proof of these requirements the presence of willfulness and bad faith on the part of the Respondent would normally be inferred, but the Respondent could rebut this inference by contrary proof on a balance of probabilities.[1]

Cameron JA in the matter of Fakie NO v CC IT Systems (Pty) Ltd [2] summed up the development of the common law in contempt proceedings and stated as follows:

“Once the Applicant proves the three requisites of contempt, namely, the order; service or notice; non – compliance and willfulness and mala fides beyond a reasonable doubt; the Respondent bears an evidential burden in relation to willfulness and mala fides that establishes a reasonable doubt as to whether non – compliance was willful and mala fide.” (my underlining)

 

And as follows:

  • The civil contempt procedure is a valuable and important mechanism for securing compliance with Court orders, and survives constitutional scrutiny in the dorm of a motion court application adapted to constitutional requirements;

 

  • the Respondent in such proceedings is not an “accused person”, but is entitled to analogous protections as are appropriate to motion proceedings;

 

  • In particular, the Applicant must prove the requisites of contempt (the order; service or notice, non – compliance and willfulness and mala fides) beyond reasonable doubt;

 

  • But, once the Applicant has proved the order, service or notice, and non – compliance, the Respondent bears an evidential burden in relation to willfulness and mala fides: Should the Respondent fail to advance evidence that establishes a reasonable doubt as to whether the non – compliance was willful and mala fide, contempt will have been established beyond a reasonable doubt;

 

  • A declaratory and other appropriate remedies remain available to a civil Applicant on proof on a balance of probabilities.”

 

Although contempt is part of a broader offence, it can take on many forms, even though its essence lies in violating the dignity, repute, or authority of the Court. Traditionally, contempt of court has been divided into two categories according to whether the contempt is criminal or civil in nature. These types of contempt are distinguished on the basis of the conduct of the person in contempt.

The relief in civil contempt proceedings can take on a variety of forms other than criminal sanctions, such as declaratory orders, mandamus, and structural interdicts. All of these remedies play an important part in the enforcement of court orders in civil contempt proceedings. Their objective is to compel parties to comply with a court order.  In some instances, the disregard of a court order may justify committal, as a sanction for past non-compliance. This is necessary because breaching a court order, willfully and with mala fides, undermines the authority of the courts and thereby adversely affects the broader public interest.

 

[1] Du Plessis v Du Plessis 1972 (4) SA 216 (O) at 220A-D

[2] [2006] ZASCA 52; 2006 (4) SA 326 (SCA) at para 42.

SPOLIATION

20180101-taking-the-law-into-your-own-hands

“Two angry women believe the law was on their side when they removed a radio station transmitter leaving Radio Houtstok FM listeners in silence. What drove these women to take such drastic action? CarteBlanche.”

 

The question is whether the two women took the law into their own hands.

 

The mandament van spolie is a possessory remedy which protects the possession of a party. It is based on the rationale that no person is allowed to take the law into his own hands and to unlawfully dispossess another of possession of property. If this occurs a court will summarily restore the status quo ante without enquiring into or investigating the merits of the dispute to determine a party’s right to ownership.

Even an unlawful possessor – a fraud, a thief or a robber is entitled to the mandament’s protection. The court will therefore remedy illicit deprivation before determining the competing claims to the object or property.

The two requirements for a spoliation order are firstly proof that the applicant was in peaceful and undisturbed possession of the spoliated item and secondly that the applicant was wrongfully deprived of its possession. The cause for possession is irrelevant and therefore even a thief’s possession is protected. Possession is not possession in the strict juridical sense and it is sufficient to proof that the possession was with the intention of securing some benefit for the Applicant. The fact that possession is wrongful or illegal is irrelevant, as that would go to the merits of the dispute.

Generally the Respondent is not entitled to challenge the applicant’s title to the spoliated item, because good title is irrelevant. There are however a qualification to the aforesaid requirements. If an applicant claims a substantive right to possession of the spoliated thing additional to the possession he in effect forces an investigation of the issues relevant to the further claim.  In the latter instance the Respondent may answer such additional claim of right and may demonstrate, if he can, that Applicant does not have the right to possession which it claims.  [1]

A spoliation application is brought ex parte which means that no notice is given to Respondent. The court will then grant a Rule Nisi calling on Respondent to show cause on a date determined by the court why the Rule Nisi should not be made final.

When orders are sought ex parte an applicant should observe the obligation of utmost good faith and should not make misstatements of any nature.  If a court finds that such misstatements were made with a fraudulent motive or mala fide it may even discharge a rule nisi obtained ex parte based on the applicant’s failure to present material facts or his serious misstatements of material facts.[2]

One of the defences open to a Respondent facing a Rule Nisi is that it is impossible to return the item because it has been destroyed, irreparably damaged or lost or/and when a third party has acquired possession of the article. The courts will not engage in the futile exercise of granting an order which cannot be carried out.[3] Where a defence of impossibility is raised the court may however order restoration if the return is impossible.

 

[1] Street Pole Ads Durban (Pty) Ltd v Ethekwini Municipality [2008] 3 ALL SA 182 (SCA)

[2] Tyjaderlin Properties CC v Malan and Another (1487/2015) [2016] ZAFSHC 5

[3] Administrator of Cape of Good Hope and Another v Ntshwaqela and Others (165/8) ZASCA 167; [1990] 2 ALL SA 34 (A) (30 November 1989)

 

Road Accident Fund

asphalt-clouds-fields-56832

 

  • What is the Road Accident Fund?

The Road Accident Fund is a public entity set up to compensate persons seriously injured in motor vehicle accidents for which they are not to blame.
In terms of section 3 of the Road Accident Fund 1996 (Act No 56 of 1996);
“the object of the Road Accident Fund shall be the payment of the compensation in accordance with this Act for loss or damage wrongfully caused by the driving of a motor vehicle.”

  • Who may claim?

The following are entitled to make a claim:

  • A person who sustained a bodily injury in the accident (except a driver who was the sole cause of the accident);
  • A dependent of a deceased breadwinner;
  • A close relative of the deceased who paid for the funeral; and
  • A claimant under the age of 18 years – who must be assisted by a parent, legal guardian or a legal representative.

  • What can you claim?
    • The injured, or the supplier, may claim the costs of accommodation in a hospital or nursing home or treatment of or rendering of a service or supplying of goods to the injured;
    • Where emergency medical treatment is provided to the injured the Fund’s liability to compensate the injured or the supplier, as the case may be, is determined in accordance with a prescribed tariff; and
    • Where the treatment provided is of a non-emergency nature, the Fund will compensate reasonable and necessary costs of the treatment to the injured, or to the supplier, as the case may be.

  • What is the time period in which to submit a claim? ​
    • Identified claims (where the identity of the driver or owner of the guilty motor vehicle is known) must be lodged with the Fund within 3 years from the date of the accident and must be finalised within 5 years from the date of accident;
    • Hit and Run claims (where the identity of the driver or owner of the guilty motor vehicle is unknown) must be lodged with the Fund within 2 years from the date of the accident and must be finalised within 5 years from the date of accident;
    • Claims in terms of an undertaking certificate issued in terms of section 17(4)(a)(ii) of the Act must be lodged and finalised within 5 years from the date on which services were rendered to the injured.
  • How to claim:

All accounts must be fully specified and must indicate exactly what service/treatment has been received. It must also reflect the date of the service or treatment, as well as the name and physical address of the service provider. It is not enough to only submit a receipt as proof that you have incurred an expense.  Make sure that the goods/service reflected in the account has been received.  Once satisfied, sign each account, that has been submitted to the Fund for reimbursement.

Write the Road Accident Fund claim reference number and/or Link number as quoted in the undertaking document, clearly on each claim.

Each road accident claim is different, and it can be difficult for someone without the appropriate legal experience to determine exactly what to include in a claim. It is therefore advised to make use of the services of an experienced attorney.

At Lötter Attorneys we will be able to guide you through the RAF claims process – from reporting the accident and gathering the necessary documentation, to submitting the claim within the prescribed time limits and negotiating with the RAF on your behalf.

Contact us today

PARENTING COORDINATOR

parent_coordinator

In TC v SC 2018 (4) SA 530 (WCC), a recent Western Cape High Court case, decided by Acting Justice Davis, the Judge noted the sad reality in divorce cases that conflict generated by the breakdown of the marital relationship often spills over into the parenting relationship. The children often become the subject of disputes about care and contact and other parenting issues.

 

The appointment of a parenting coordinator has become a regular feature of divorce litigation where the interests of children are in issue. To manage the negative impact on children, the court appoints a parenting coordinator to provide a non-adversarial dispute resolution service. The persons appointed are often child psychologists or family law practitioners, who assist to resolve child-related disputes in an expeditious and child-focused manner, to minimise the risks that the parental conflict hold for children.

 

In South Africa there is currently no statute or rule of court governing the appointment of a parenting coordinator, but a practice has developed in the Western Cape which entails that the divorcing parents consent to the appointment of a parenting coordinator to mediate parenting disputes. The court also authorises the coordinator to give directives on the child-related issues in dispute, if the mediation is not successful. These directives are binding, unless it is set aside by the court.

 

The main issue in TC v SC was whether the High Court has the power, by virtue of its inherent jurisdiction as the upper guardian of minor children, to make an interim order appointing a facilitator to deal with parenting disputes, even if one of the parents objects.

 

Acting Justice Davis stated that the court-assigned role for the parenting coordinator can be crafted in a manner which will not constitute an unlawful delegation of the Court’s decision-making authority. She proposed that the following limitations be placed on the powers of a parenting coordinator:

 

  1. Agreement between the parties must have been reached and set out in a parenting plan, whether interim or final, and must have been made an order of court. The parenting coordinator’s role must be limited to ensuring implementation of or compliance with the existing court order. This eliminates the risk of an improper delegation of judicial decision-making power.
  2. The parenting coordinator’s decision-making power must be confined to ancillary rulings that may be necessary to implement the court order, without altering the substance of the court order or involving a permanent change to any of the rights and obligations defined in the court order, so ensuring that the parenting coordinator does not trespass on the Court’s exclusive jurisdiction.
  3. All decisions made by the parenting coordinator must be subject to comprehensive judicial oversight in the form of a full reconsideration of the decision, accordingly suspending the finality of the decision and giving the Court the authority to alter the decision.

 

Acting Justice Davis made it clear that in the absence of the consent of the parties to the appointment of a coordinator and the terms of their appointment, a court should not impose a coordinator on parties without conducting the necessary inquiries and making findings regarding the following:

  1. the welfare of the child is at risk from exposure to chronic parental conflict based on evidence of the parents’ inability or unwillingness to co-parent peacefully;
  2. mediation has been attempted and was unsuccessful, or is inappropriate in the particular case;
  3. the person proposed for appointment as the coordinator is suitably qualified and experienced to fulfil the role of coordinator;
  4. the fees charged by the proposed coordinator are fair and reasonable in the light of their qualifications and experience, that the parents can afford to pay for the services of the coordinator, and that at least one of the parents agrees to pay for the services of the coordinator.

 

In terms of this judgment parenting coordinators may only issue directives directly implementing the terms of a parenting plan which has been made an order of court, without altering its substance or changing the rights and obligations set out in the Court Order. The practical impact of this ruling is that the parenting coordinator’s ability to manage high-conflict divorce situations is limited and, for example, he/she will not be able to amend the parenting plan in the event of a change in circumstances which impact on the maintenance to be paid for the minor child or the care and contact arrangements or other safety measures designed to serve the best interest of a minor child. In view of the significant role played by parenting coordinators in divorce matters, these limitations and the Court’s formulation of the powers of the parenting coordinator is of great importance.

 

INTERIM RELIEF – RULE 43 APPLICATIONS

prentjie

Rule 43 Applications – Interim Relief

Divorce proceedings can sometime takes months and/or years to finalise and the law provides a mechanism that can be used to assist spouses during a divorce to provide for much needed interim relief until the divorce is finalised. An extremely acrimonious divorce can take years to finalise and spouses need to be safeguarded during the divorce process.

 

A Rule 43 in the High Court (known as a Rule 58 in the Magistrate’s court) provides an interim measure to help an Applicant fairly quickly.

 

WHAT is a Rule 43/58?

A Rule 43/58 can be used for one or more of the following:

  • maintenance towards the wife and/or children;
  • interim care or contact with the child;
  • enforcing certain payments, such as for the bond on the matrimonial home, vehicles, school fees, medical aid premiums and even deposits on new accommodation and relocation costs;
  • interim contribution towards the costs of the divorce and legal fees;

WHEN?

 

In terms of the equality provisions in the Constitution, a divorcing wife/husband who has no income is entitled to a contribution to her/his legal costs to ensure she/he has an equal opportunity to defend her/his case. Depending on the circumstances, such an application can be brought:

(i) before issuing of the summons;

(ii) simultaneously with the issuing of the summons; or

(iii) after a notice of intention to defend is received.

 

NB:

An applicant is entitled to interim relief depending on the living standards of the parties. In applications of this nature, an applicant must show that he/she has insufficient means and that the respondent can afford to meet the amounts being sought.

 

PROCEDURE:

The spouse seeking an interim relief order (the applicant) will file a notice and affidavit (referred to as a founding affidavit) with the court setting out the facts relating to the divorce and why the spouse is of the opinion that he/she is entitled to relief from the spouse against whom relief is sought (the respondent).

 

RESPONDENT:

It is up to the respondent to provide the court with evidence that disputes the applicant’s claim, as the case may be. If the respondent does not do so, the court is entitled to infer from the evidence at hand that he/she can afford to pay the interim relief.

 

CONCLUSION

The spirit of rule 43/58 demands that the applicant provide a very brief, succinct statement of the reasons why he/she is asking for the relief claimed and that the respondent supply an equally succinct reply. The court must then to do its best to arrive expeditiously at a decision. At the hearing of the rule 43/58 application, no oral evidence is given and the application is argued based on the documentation before the court. The judge or magistrate will make an order as he/she deems appropriate under the circumstances.

Co-ownership

3-1

“COMMUNIO EST MATER RIXARUM!”

The maxim communion est mater rixarum  means – co-ownership is the mother of disputes!

As a general rule, every co-owner is entitled to have co-ownership terminated.  The relief is founded on the action communi dividundo which originated in Roman Law and cascaded from Roman Dutch Law to South African law.  Such an action has two purposes, namely (1) division of the joint property and (2) payment of profits enjoyed or expenses incurred in connection with the property.  A co-owner may at any time insist on partition of the property.  Robson v Theron 1978(1) SA 841(A) at 854H-855A.

If co-owners cannot agree on the manner in which to divide the Court is empowered to make such an order as appears to be fair and equitable in the circumstances. The court may for example entitle one of the co-owners to obtain the whole of the property upon payment of a certain sum.  If this is not possible, the court may order the property to be sold and proceeds to be divided amongst the co-owners according to their shares. This might include a sale by public auction.

The co-owner who wishes to terminate co-ownership has to prove the existence of co-ownership and that the other co-owner refuses to agree to termination of joint ownership and that they cannot agree to the method of termination or the terms of an agreement relating to termination.

It is important to know that a partnership is completely different from co-ownership.  Partnerships are of wider ambit and partners may be co-owners, but co-owners are in the absence of clear evidence not partners.  Oblowitz v Obliwitz 1953(4) SA 426 at 433 (A-B). In this case the court differentiate between the two terms as follows:

  • Co-owners is not necessarily the result of agreement whilst partnership is;
  • Co-owners does not necessarily involve community of profit and loss whilst partnership does;
  • One co-owner can without consent alienate his share in the property whereas as a partner is;
  • One co-owner is as such the agent of the others, whereas a partner is;
  • Co-ownership need not exist for sake of gain or profit, whereas this is an element fundamental to legal conception of a partnership;

 

Defamation

truth

DEFAMATION

The wrong of defamation is committed whenever an individual wrongfully and intentionally publishes a defamatory statement/comment about another person which has the effect of lowering that individual’s good name/reputation.

Example:

A group of people are having lunch in a restaurant. One individual verbally expresses her disgust by using foul language and makes a defamatory statement about a third party who was not present at the lunch.

Characteristics:

  • Wrongfulness / unlawful

The comment must be made contra bonos mores (against public policy). It simply means that the statement must be regarded as wrongful and unacceptable. In other words, will the reasonable objective person understand the statement in a negative light?

 

  • Intention

The individual committing the defamation must intentionally focus his/her will on damaging the reputation of the other person and must have known that said statement is wrongful.

 

  • Publication

Defamation of someone’s character can only occur when such statement is communicated by one person to another i.e through publication thereof.

It is crucial to note that publication does not only include writing, but also verbal communication and may even include the use of body language or hand gestures.

 

Onus of proof

  1. The person whose reputation was attacked bears the onus of proving that the statement was defamatory.
  2. However, the law assists the person by creating a presumption that the defamer made the statement intentionally and unlawfully.
  3. This presumption then causes a shift so that the defamer needs to prove that there is no claim.

 

It does not matter whether 1 or 10 or a 100 people heard/read the statement, the mere fact that a single party (a third party) heard the statement, causes the requirement to be met.

 

Defences

There are three defences that are commonly used to justify a defamatory statement

  1. Truth and in the public interest / public benefit

The defamer must be able to prove that the statement is substantially true and that the public has an advantage or legitimate interest therein. The question is therefore whether the statement ought to be published and not whether the public wants certain statements to be published.

 

  1. Fair comment

One has the freedom of expression and the expression of such an opinion is protected, HOWEVER in order for such an opinion to be protected it must be (a) based on facts AND it must be (b) a matter of public interest.

 

  1. Privileged occasion

There must be a specific relationship between the two individuals, such as an attorney-client relationship, for the said statement to be regarded as privileged. Whether the comment that was made is true or untrue, it will not matter.

 

Damages

Any and all statements which diminishes a person’s reputation and which were made with such intentions by the defamer, gives the defamed person grounds for an action for damages for defamation. One does not have to prove actual loss and there is no scale for measuring damages. Damages will be calculated on the basis of the harm done to the person’s reputation.

 

The court will look at and consider:

  • Malice and the nature and extent of the publication;
  • The presence or absence of an adequate apology; and
  • Rank/social/professional status of the person whose reputation was damaged

 

Conclusion

It is therefore clear, that a person cannot and may not and will not be protected if she makes statements moved by jealousy, which is not based on facts or in the interest of the public. Therefor defamatory statements includes “not only statements that expose a person to hatred, contempt or ridicule, but also statements that are likely to humiliate or belittle the plaintiff; which tend to make him/her look foolish, ridiculous or absurd or which render the plaintiff less worthy of respect by his or her peers.” (Nadia van der Westhuizen v Morgan Motlogelwa Ntshabelele 2014/27063)

Domestic Violence

domestic-violence-image

DOMESTIC VIOLENCE

“It cuts across class, race, culture and geography and is all the more pernicious because it is so often concealed and so frequently goes unpunished.” [S v Baloyi 2000 (2) SA 425 (CC) 11]

 

  1. Domestic Violence Act 116 of 1998:

This Act affords women protection from domestic violence by creating obligations on law enforcement, such as the South African Police Service, to protect victims of abuse. The Act recognises that domestic violence is a serious crime and protects not only married woman, but unmarried women, same-sex partners, children and other individuals who share a common living space.

 

  1. Types of domestic violence:
  • Physical abuse

Any act or threatened act of violence towards a victim. It also includes physical injury onto other targets, such as children or pets, in order to cause psychological harm to a victim

 

  • Sexual abuse

Any conduct that abuses, humiliates, degrades, or otherwise violates the sexual integrity of the victim. Such abuse can be done by any person regardless of their relationship to the victim and can occur in any setting, including but not limited to home or work.

 

  • Emotional, verbal and psychological abuse

It usually constitutes a pattern of degrading or humiliating conduct towards a victim, whether it is done publicly or privately.

Examples: insults, ridicule, name calling, threats to cause emotional pain, obsessive possessiveness and/or jealousy which constitute a serious invasion of the victim’s liberty, privacy and security. Further examples: isolating the victim from family and friends and controlling what the victim may and may not do.

 

  • Economic abuse

Economic abuse may involve preventing or limiting a victim’s resource acquisition, or the resources available to the victim or the exploitation of the victim’s economic resources. It might also be the case where the abuser closely monitors the victim by providing an allowance to the victim and in a way preventing the victim from acquiring help and to force the victim to remain financially dependent.

 

  • Intimidation

Uttering or conveying a threat, or causing a victim to receive a threat, which includes fear in order to scare the victim into submission. The idea with such behaviour is to convey to the victim, that if the victim does not obey, non-obedience may/will lead to violence

 

  • Harassment

Engaging in a pattern of conduct that induces a fear of harm in the victim, including repeatedly watching the victim, loitering outside of or near the building/place/home where the victim resides, works, studies or just happens to be. Other examples: repeatedly telephoning the victim or inducing other persons to make telephone calls to the victim; repeatedly sending, delivering letters, emails, messages, packages or other objects.

 

  • Stalking

When the abuser repeatedly follows, pursues or approaches the victim. There is no legal definition of the term stalking, however it is used to define a very specific form of harassment.

 

  • Damage to property

 

  • Entry into the victim’s residence without consent (in the case where the parties do not share a common residence)

 

  • Any other controlling or abusive behaviour

Examples: the abuser is in the possession of firearms and has threatened to use it, the victim fears for the safety of not only herself but of her children, the victim has been injured before by the abuser, the victim has sufficient evidence that the abuser has threatened to harm her.

 

  1. The Protection Order:

3.1. What is it?

A protection order is also known as a restraining order or domestic violence interdict. This order is a Court Order which forces the abuser to stop the abuse and it sets out certain conditions which prevent the abuser from further harassing or abusing the victim in the future.

 

3.2. Who can apply and when?

  • ANY individual may approach the Magistrates Court nearest to where they reside or work. Even a minor (an individual younger than 18 years) may apply without the assistance of a parent or guardian.
  • One may apply at ANY time (during or outside of court hours as well as weekends or public holidays)

 

3.3. Steps:

  • One must first apply for an Interim Protection Order by completing Form 6 at the nearest Magistrate’s Court or High Court
  • Once you have applied for the Interim Order, one must complete Form 2 which is the application for a Protection Order.

 

The applications must be made by way of an affidavit (document), which must state:

  • The facts on which the application is based
  • Nature of the order
  • The name of the police station where the victim is likely to report a breach of the order

3.4 What happens then?

Once the application is made and the court is satisfied with the facts, the court must immediately issue an interim protection order against the abuser. An interim order will then be served on the abuser, which will include a return date on which date the abuser must show cause why a final order should not be issued. A Protection Order is enforceable throughout the whole of South Africa and it will remain in force until it is set aside.

 

3.5 Assistance

The court may issue any conditions which it deems fit. The court may also order that a peace office accompany the victim to place of residence or a specified place regarding the collection of personal property. The court may also order the abuser to pay emergency monies to the victim.

 

  1. Breach of the Protection Order

Once a final protection order is issued by the Court and the abuser acts in contravention thereof, criminal prosecution of the abuser may follow.

 

FORMS: